Monday, February 20, 2012

Irascible and Concupiscible Appetites

Nick recently shared this short article on Sense Appetite which briefly discusses the distinction and relation between the irascible and concupiscible appetites.

We understand these passions to be distinct because they can be opposed to each other. For the person whose virtues are ordered due to continued cooperation with grace, would St. Thomas maintain the distinction between the two as being opposed to one another? In other words, is the distinction between these appetites only due to natural concupiscence without supernatural grace?

1 comment:

  1. Kyle, the distinction in the passions would exist even were it not for the taint of original sin. In other words, this distinction would exist even in the state of pure nature and even in the state of prelapsarian man. For a detailed exposition, reference St. Thomas's Treatise on Man (especially Ia, qq. 77, 80, and 81). Two faculties of the soul are the same if and only if their formal objects are the same. St. Thomas distinguished between the sensitive and intellectual appetites because the sensitive appetites and the intellectual appetites have different objects (which he discusses in Ia, q. 80, a. 2). He states that the sensitive power is a genus of powers containing two distinct species: the irascible and the concupiscible. The object of the concupiscible appetite is the easy good, whereas the object of the irascible appetite is the arduous good. (cf. Ia, q. 81, a. 2) Hence the concupiscible appetite of Christ, who was not injured by any defect of original sin including disordered passions, sought to flee the cross, whereas the irascible appetite sought to defeat Satan in the cross. However, Christ, who even in His humanity had a rational nature, directed both of these appetites by His will choosing to fulfill the irascible rather than the concupiscible in keeping with His divine will by which all things were decreed.

    I hope that sufficiently answers your question.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.